7 Best Jamaican Allspice Berries to Buy Now

Ever wished your spice rack had a little more oomph? Meet Jamaican allspice berries, the secret weapon of Caribbean kitchens! These fragrant little wonders, also known as pimento berries, aren't just pretty; they pack a warm, complex flavor profile – a delightful blend of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. Add a pinch to your stews, rubs, or even baked goods for a taste of island sunshine and a depth of flavor that'll have everyone asking for more. Discover the magic of Jamaican allspice berries and elevate your cooking!

This list helps consumers make informed purchasing decisions. By considering factors like material, heat retention, size, and ease of cleaning, buyers can choose a product that meets their needs and delivers optimal cooking results, leading to a superior final product. This ensures satisfaction and avoids disappointment.

1. Walkerswood Jamaican Jerk Seasoning Combo Pack (Hot & Mild, 10oz, 2-pack)

Authentic Jamaican jerk flavor, versatile, and easy to use!

Walkerswood Jamaican Jerk Seasoning Combo Pack (Hot & Mild, 10oz, 2-pack)
    Highly rated
  • Taste
  • Spice level
  • Durability
    Some controversy about
  • Heat level
  • Leakage

Bring the taste of authentic Jamaica to your kitchen with Walkerswood's Traditional Jamaican Jerk Seasoning Combo Pack. This pack includes both hot & spicy and mild versions of their award-winning seasoning, allowing you to adjust the heat to your preference. Made with fresh, locally-sourced Jamaican ingredients, including Scotch Bonnet peppers and allspice, this versatile seasoning adds a delicious kick to chicken, lamb, pork, fish, and vegetables. Simply rub it into your chosen protein, marinate overnight for optimal flavor, then grill, bake, or slow-cook to perfection. Experience the authentic taste of Jamaican jerk, lauded by Men's Health Magazine as the Best World Food Seasoning.

Walkerswood Traditional Jamaican Jerk Seasoning consistently receives rave reviews for its authentic flavor and ease of use. Users praise its delicious blend of spices, describing the taste as rich, flavorful, and aromatic, with a perfect balance of heat and sweetness (even in the "mild" version). Many appreciate its convenience, noting that it saves time compared to making jerk seasoning from scratch. The seasoning's versatility shines through, with users successfully employing it on chicken, pork, ribs, lamb, and fish, achieving tender and juicy results every time. Its thick consistency ensures even coating and deep flavor penetration. While some find the "mild" option still has a noticeable kick, this is generally considered a positive aspect, especially for those who enjoy a bit of spice. The product's popularity is underscored by long-time users and those who have found it transforms their cooking. Overall, Walkerswood Jerk Seasoning is highly recommended for adding authentic Jamaican flavor to a variety of dishes.

  • Brand: WALKERSWOOD
  • Item Form: Powder
  • Unit Count: 20 Ounce
  • Rate: 4.6 / 2559

2. Easispice Jamaican All-Purpose Seasoning (400g)

Amazing Jamaican flavor, versatile and great value!

Easispice Jamaican All-Purpose Seasoning (400g)
    Highly rated
  • Flavor
  • Value for money

Elevate your culinary creations with Easispice Jamaican All Purpose Seasoning. This 400g (14 oz) jar is packed with a vibrant blend of authentic Jamaican spices, perfect for adding bold flavor to any dish. Its versatile formula works wonders on meats, poultry, fish, vegetables, and more, simplifying your cooking process while delivering rich, Caribbean-inspired taste. From everyday meals to special occasions, Easispice guarantees a delicious depth of flavor with just a sprinkle. Experience the convenience and exceptional taste of authentic Jamaican seasoning in every bite.

This Jamaican allspice is a fantastic addition to any kitchen. Users rave about its authentic flavor, describing it as one of Jamaica's best and a staple ingredient for creating incredibly yummy meals. It works well on all meats and significantly enhances the taste of various dishes. The generous quantity offered provides excellent value, and the resealable bag helps maintain freshness. While some users noted a slight difference in color from the advertisement and a lack of specific usage instructions, the overwhelmingly positive feedback highlights the exceptional taste and quality of this allspice. It's a must-have for anyone looking to add authentic Jamaican flair to their cooking.

  • Brand: Skyvov
  • Item Form: Powder
  • Unit Count: 14 Ounce
  • Rate: 4.4 / 197

3. Organic Allspice Berries (1 lb): Baking, Pickling, Soups, Marinades

Fresh, flavorful allspice—a delightful aroma and long-lasting taste.

Organic Allspice Berries (1 lb): Baking, Pickling, Soups, Marinades
    Highly rated
  • Flavor
  • Quality
  • Spice content
  • Aroma
  • Freshness
  • Value for money

Frontier Co-op Organic Whole Allspice Berries offer a convenient and flavorful way to elevate your culinary creations. This 1-pound bulk bag provides a generous supply of these aromatic berries, perfect for baking, pickling, soups, and marinades. Their intense, warm flavor, a blend of clove, cinnamon, and nutmeg, adds depth and complexity to a wide range of dishes. Sourced organically and certified vegan, these allspice berries are a high-quality, versatile ingredient for both seasoned cooks and culinary adventurers.

This allspice is a fantastic find! Users rave about its intensely fresh aroma and delicious flavor, describing it as "wonderful," "delicious," and having a "fantastic and long-lasting" scent. Many appreciate its versatility, using it successfully in everything from simmer pot satchels and oatmeal to jerk seasoning and homemade tea. The quality is consistently praised, with descriptions like "fresh," and "perfect for what I was looking for." One user even highlighted the surprisingly fast rate of use despite a long shelf life, suggesting superior quality and desirability. While some users mentioned a preference for resealable packaging, the overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive, making this allspice a highly recommended purchase for anyone needing a high-quality, flavorful spice.

  • Brand: Frontier Co-op
  • Item Form: Berries
  • Unit Count: 16.0 Ounce
  • Rate: 4.9 / 188

4. Spice Way Juniper, Allspice & Star Anise Blend (11 oz)

Spice Way Juniper, Allspice & Star Anise Blend (11 oz)

Experience the rich flavors of The Spice Way's premium spice collection, featuring 4 oz of Juniper Berries, 4 oz of Allspice, and 3 oz of Star Anise. Grown using traditional methods on our family farm for over 30 years, these spices are hand-picked, sun-dried, and completely pure – no preservatives, additives, or fillers. Juniper berries add a unique zest to meats, poultry, fish, and drinks; allspice lends depth to both sweet and savory dishes; and star anise offers a distinctive licorice-like flavor perfect for cooking, baking, and tea. Enjoy the farm-to-table freshness and unparalleled quality of these exceptional spices.

  • Brand: The Spice Way
  • Item Form: Whole
  • Unit Count: 1.0 Count
  • Rate: 5 / 1

5. Happy Belly Allspice Ground (2 x 2.5 oz)

Fresh, flavorful, affordable spice—a kitchen essential!

Happy Belly Allspice Ground (2 x 2.5 oz)
    Highly rated
  • Taste
  • Value for money
  • Aroma
  • Quality
  • Freshness
  • Size

Spice up your cooking with Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Allspice Ground. This convenient two-pack provides 2.5 ounces of premium allspice, perfect for adding warmth and complexity to a wide range of dishes. Its rich, aromatic flavor blends perfectly in both sweet and savory recipes, from hearty stews and savory rubs to baked goods and holiday treats. The ground allspice is easily incorporated into your favorite culinary creations, offering a versatile and flavorful addition to your spice rack. Enjoy the consistent quality and value of Happy Belly, ensuring your dishes are always bursting with delicious flavor.

This allspice is a fantastic find! Customers consistently praise its fresh aroma and delicious flavor, perfect for enhancing everything from peach pies to coffee and ice cream. The price is excellent for the size, and many appreciate the convenience of online ordering, especially since allspice isn't always readily available in stores. Delivery is fast, and overall, users report a highly positive experience with this high-quality spice. It's a keeper!

  • Brand: Happy Belly
  • Item Form: Powder
  • Unit Count: 5.0 Ounce
  • Rate: 4.7 / 4278

6. Plant Therapy Allspice Essential Oil (10ml, 100% Pure)

High-quality, warm, spicy scent; perfect for autumn.

Plant Therapy Allspice Essential Oil (10ml, 100% Pure)

Experience the warm, inviting aroma of Plant Therapy's 100% pure, undiluted Allspice Essential Oil. This therapeutic-grade oil, steam-distilled from Pimento Tree berries, is perfect for supporting healthy digestion when used topically (diluted with a carrier oil). Its rich scent blends beautifully with other oils like Sweet Orange and Cinnamon Leaf for a comforting autumnal fragrance in your diffuser. Each bottle undergoes rigorous testing, including GC-MS analysis, ensuring the highest quality. With its versatile uses and enticing fragrance, Plant Therapy's Allspice Essential Oil is a valuable addition to any aromatherapy collection. Certified aromatherapists are available to answer any questions you may have.

Plant Therapy Allspice Essential Oil is a high-quality, wonderfully aromatic oil praised for its warm, spicy scent reminiscent of cinnamon, cloves, and pepper. Users describe the fragrance as comforting, evoking feelings of warmth and the cozy aromas of autumn baking (pumpkin pies and spiced cider). The blend is well-balanced, not overpowering, and easily diffused, with a lasting scent that permeates a space nicely, even with just a few drops. Many users appreciate its versatility, using it in diffusers, potpourri, and even in lotions. The oil is considered gentle enough for sensitive noses, and one user successfully combined it with other oils for a custom blend. Its quality and effectiveness are repeatedly highlighted, making it a favorite among Plant Therapy customers.

  • Brand: Plant Therapy
  • Rate: 4.7 / 178

7. Spice Islands Allspice (2 x 1.8 oz)

Amazing flavor, versatile, and excellent quality at a great price!

Spice Islands Allspice (2 x 1.8 oz)
    Highly rated
  • Flavor
  • Smell
  • Quality
  • Value for money

Spice Islands Ground Allspice offers the warm, pungent flavor of allspice berries in a convenient two-pack of 1.8-ounce containers. This versatile spice is perfect for both sweet and savory dishes, adding a unique depth of flavor to everything from baked goods and jams to stews and rubs. Its finely ground consistency ensures easy incorporation into your recipes, while the double pack provides a generous supply for all your culinary creations. Enjoy the rich aroma and complex flavor profile of this high-quality allspice, a staple in any well-stocked spice rack.

Spice Island Allspice is a high-quality spice delivering exceptional flavor and aroma. Users rave about its versatility, enjoying it in a wide range of dishes, from oatmeal and yogurt to toast, coffee, and even pies. Many appreciate the convenient glass jar and long-lasting freshness. Reviewers consistently praise the delicious taste and smell, describing it as "heavenly" and a perfect way to add zest to various foods. The excellent price point adds to the overall value, making this allspice a must-have for any spice cabinet.

  • Brand: Spice Islands
  • Item Form: Powder
  • Unit Count: 3.6 Ounce
  • Rate: 4.8 / 321